You May Like
Odie Play By Play Large 36" T Carnival Game Prize Plush Stuffed Animal Garfield
$100.00
View Details
RARE Huge Jumbo Garfield The Cat Plush Paws Play-By-Play Approx. 36” 3 Foot Tall
$99.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush Jumbo Cat Paws Play-By-Play Plush 42” in “Official” Rare
$299.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Odie Dog Plush Large Play by Play with Tag 22”
$24.99
View Details
Vintage Play By Play Paws 15" Garfield ODIE Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy NWT
$24.00
View Details
Vintage Paws GARFIELD Plush Toy 10” Stuffed Animal Play By Play E
$14.00
View Details
Vintage Odie Plush Friend Garfield by Jim Davis Play by Play Paws 7”
$5.95
View Details
Garfield The Cat PAWS Play by Play Toy Vintage 11” Stuffed Plush
$11.19
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal Play by Play PAWS Laying Down 90s
$11.95
View Details
GARFIELD ULTRA RARE Vintage Plush 16" Long Legs and Long Arms Plush Adorable!
$170.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield BIG 2 Ft Play-by-Play Jumbo Plush Appro 24-26” Stuffed Animal
$129.89
View Details
Vintage 12" Odie Plush Garfield Dog Play By Play Paws Stuffed Big Original Tag
$21.88
View Details
Vtg Play-By-Play Garfield The Artist Plush 1983 Smock Paintbrush Bow Tie HTF
$24.99
View Details
VINTAGE GARFIELD PLAY BY PLAY 9" PLUSH NEW WITH TAGS
$10.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield BIG 2 Ft Play-by-Play Jumbo Plush Rare
$30.00
View Details
Vintage Play By Play Garfield 12” Odie Stuffed Animal Plush Dog
$15.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield Soft Plush Toy Play-by-Play 11.5”
$16.00
View Details
Vintage Dakin Garfield Plush Stuffed Animals Holiday Christmas Pick Your Plush
$17.49
View Details
Large Odie Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal 22" Has hang tag Play By Play
$30.00
View Details
Lot of 2 Garfield and Odie Plush Play By Play 7" Cartoon Used Toy Stuffed Animal
$16.99
View Details
BIG VINTAGE Lot Of Garfield Plushes & Other Collection RARE Dakin Paws
$325.00
View Details
VTG Play by Play Laying Odie from Garfield Plush Yellow 9"
$9.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal by Play by Play PAWS Laying Down Garf Mart
$19.99
View Details
Vintage 90's Large Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal Play by Play? PAWS Laying Down
$22.80
View Details
VTG Garfield Fill Er Up 9" Christmas Plush 1981 Dakin PlayThings NWT W/Lil Bear
$40.00
View Details
Rare Vintage Play By Play Odie (Garfield by Jim Davis) 9” Dog Plush
$19.99
View Details
Vintage Rare 1978 Garfield Plush Cat Dog Pet Bed/Toy Box
$48.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Cast Of Characters Spencer’s Nylon Plush 24" New w/tag
$49.99
View Details
Vintage 1983 Mattel Talking Grumpy Moving Eyes Garfield Plush Hong Kong
$75.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Cast Of Characters Spencer’s Nylon Plush 20”
$29.99
View Details
Garfield Play By Play Ball Baseball Cap Plush Toy NEW In Box *Rare*
$39.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield The Cat By PAWS Play By Play 11” Stuffed Plush Jim Davis W/Tag
$20.00
View Details
Garfield PAWS play by play Plush Stuffed Animal Odie the dog 19 Inch Toy
$29.99
View Details
Garfield big plush play by play new the movie toy factory cat 13 inch doll life
$25.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal by Play by Play PAWS Laying Down 9" long
$7.95
View Details
Play By Play VTG Reclined Sitting Garfield Orange Cat Soft Plush 8” Size
$12.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal Paws Play By Play 24” Tall
$39.99
View Details
Large Garfield Paws Plush Play By Play Stuffed Toy 17"
$29.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield The Cat By PAWS Play By Play 16” Stuffed Plush Jim Davis
$24.99
View Details
1981 Vintage Garfield Cat Standing All Fours Plush Dakin
$18.95
View Details
Large Vintage Garfield The Cat By PAWS Play By Play ~15” Stuffed Plush Jim Davis
$15.00
View Details
SEALED!!! Garfield + Odie Macy's 25 Years Plush Brand New!
$25.00
View Details
Garfield the Cat PAWS Play by Play Toy Vintage 12” long 8" tall Plush Squatting
$14.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Huge Plush. By Play By Play 4ft
$3000.00
View Details
Garfield Vintage Plush Cat Holding Bear PAWS Play By Play
$13.49
View Details
Garfield Standing On All Four Legs 1978, 1981 Fun Farm Vintage Plush Cat 11"
$9.99
View Details
Odie Plush Friend Garfield by Jim Davis Play by Play Paws 7”
$14.00
View Details
Vintage Dakin Garfield Plush White Hacthable Egg Toy Have a Grade A Easter Tags
$24.99
View Details
RARE Swivel Head Garfield Stick Up Suction Cup Make My Day Plush Tags Excellent
$39.95
View Details
Vintage 90's Large Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal Play by Play PAWS Laying Down
$29.95
View Details
Large Vintage Garfield The Cat By PAWS Play By Play 16” Stuffed Plush Jim Davis
$25.00
View Details
Vtg 1978-1981 Garfield Fun Farm Plush Stuffed Animal Cat 10” standing all fours
$22.00
View Details
VTG Garfield In Pajamas & Slippers Plush Purple Play by Play Toys Stuffed NWT
$20.99
View Details
Paws Play by Play Stuffed Garfield Cat LARGE 16" WITH TAG
$16.99
View Details
GARFIELD Plush With Window Suction Cups - PAWS.Play By Play Vintage
$20.00
View Details
Garfield Jumbo Paws 28" 5.5lbs Plush Stuffed Animal - Vintage 1978 Fine Toy Co.
$93.50
View Details
Vintage Garfield The Cat By PAWS Play By Play 11” Stuffed Plush Jim Davis W/Tag
$24.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield Play By Play Plush 11" Stuffed Toy
$13.50
View Details
Vintage Extra Large Garfield Plush Jumbo 3” Foot Plush Play By Play Toys RARE
$510.00
View Details
Vtg LARGE GARFIELD THE CAT Plushie 1981 Dakin w/ Heart Picture Frame Purrfect ⭐️
$23.20
View Details
Garfield Vintage Odie Dog Play by Play Plush 14" NWT
$15.40
View Details
Vintage GARFIELD Plush 15" tall - Play by Play- No tag- Flaws
$19.99
View Details
VTG Play by Play Laying Odie from Garfield Plush Yellow 9"
$12.00
View Details
Vintage Odie Plush Friend Garfield by Jim Davis Play by Play Paws 7”
$6.74
View Details
Vintage Garfield 11.5” Plush Stuffed Animal Paws Play By Play Cat “NEW”
$22.00
View Details
Garfield Plush 16” In PJ Vintage Toy Teddy Bear Night Cap Shirt & Slippers Lot 2
$30.00
View Details
Vintage Odie Garfield Dog Plush, Original Tag, Play by Play 1999 PAWS Toy
$9.00
View Details
Vintage 15” Garfield Plush 1978, 1981 Fun Farm Cat
$18.99
View Details
Vintage Garfield Plush - 1978 Fine Toy Paws - New w/ Tag Retro Doll "Wanna Play"
$44.99
View Details
Garfield Odie Plush Stuffed Animal Cartoon Dog 19" Tall With Tag Play By Play
$29.95
View Details
VTG Lot Of 1978 1981 Dakin Garfield Plush Stuffed Animals & 2 Glasses
$165.00
View Details
Vintage 1981 Dakin Garfield Plush Toys Set of 2 W Large Eyes & Grumpy Expression
$39.00
View Details
GARFIELD Plush With Window Suction Cups - PAWS.Play By Play
$14.97
View Details
16" VINTAGE GARFIELD THE CAT PLUSH Play By Play
$27.20
View Details
Play By Play Laying & Licking Garfield's ODIE 12" Long
$19.79
View Details
Vintage 9” Talking GARFIELD Cat Pull String Plush 1983 Mattel
$24.00
View Details
Garfield The Cat By PAWS 22” Standing Stuffed Plush Jim Davis Pristine Condition
$24.99
View Details
Odie Dog Vintage 8.5" Plush : Play by Play : PAWS : Garfield
$12.50
View Details
12 inch Dakin 1978, 1981 plush Garfield. Standing with clasped hands. VGUC
$11.19
View Details
Vtg Garfield 16" Large Plush Stuffed Animal Play by Play PAWS, Laying Down
$21.24
View Details
Vintage 90s Spencers Large 26" Garfield Cat & Odie Dog Stuffed Plush Toys AS IS
$9.99
View Details
Danbury Mint Bedtime For Odie 18” Plush Jim Davis Garfield Collector's Wood Base
$149.99
View Details
Vintage 1981 Dakin Sitting GARFIELD Plush 10" & Dad Chip Off Old Block Figurine
$34.00
View Details
Garfield Wrestling Champ Plush 11"/26cm - 1978, 1981 Fun Farm Dakin Vintage (61)
$11.99
View Details
Vintage Paws GARFIELD Plush Toy 12” Stuffed Animal Play By Play NICE CONDITION!
$25.49
View Details
Garfields Odie, x 2, Play by Play Paws Large Plush and Ty Small Beanie baby
$19.95
View Details
“SAMPLE” RARE Garfield Boxer Plush! Good Condition
$90.00
View Details
Lot of 14 Vintage GARFIELD Plush Pajamas Easter Chef King Basketball Uncle Sam
$150.00
View Details
Vintage Garfield Macy's 25th Birthday Special Edition Plush With book
$24.99
View Details
Vintage Odie Garfield Dog Plush, Original Tag, Play by Play, 1999, PAWS Toy
$15.98
View Details
Garfield Plush 12 inch. Nanco/ Paws. Preowned
$11.99
View Details
Garfield Plush stuffed animal Multicolor Pretend Play Collectible *
$17.49
View Details
Vintage Garfield Cat with Pajamas & Mouse Slippers Stuffed Animal Plush Toy 24"
$29.99
View Details