You May Like
OLD JUDGE TOBACCO TIN SIGN BULLDOG BULL DOG PIPE GOODWIN AMERICAN TRADING CARDS
$23.27
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Joe "The Socker" Strauss Omaha Nebraska (WA) SGC RARE
$349.99
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Henry "Hank" Gastreich Columbus AA SGC pose 181-1 RARE
$299.99
View Details
1880's Antique Style Old Judge Tobacco Baseball Card Advertising Trade Sign 6x24
$39.95
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #310-3 Jack McGeachy Catch SGC 1 Goodwin & Co
$499.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card MIKE SLATTERY New York SGC 2 GD
$750.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Bill George New York Giants 184-2 National League SGC
$349.99
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William Schenkel Milwaukee Western Assoc SGC pose 401-3 RARE
$349.99
View Details
c1890 Victorian Trade Card Old Judge Cigarettes, Tobacco, Goodwin & Co.
$29.99
View Details
1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 254-5 SGC A $10,000 King Kelly Great Image!
$16889.00
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge N172 Gus Albert Tobacco Baseball Card Milwaukee Low Grade
$249.99
View Details
1887 OLD JUDGE CIGARETTE Tobacco Fido Mark Baldwin Chicago White Stockings SGC 4
$999.99
View Details
c1890 Victorian Trade Card Old Judge Cigarettes, Tobacco, Goodwin & Co.
$29.99
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge N172 Bobby Wheelock Tobacco Baseball Card Boston Low Grade
$349.99
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG
$895.00
View Details
E008 Old Judge Cigarettes trade card Goodwin Co NY false medical claim tobacco
$29.50
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Dan Casey Philadelphia Phillies PSA pose 72-3 RARE
$459.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes John Clarkson SGC 10 POOR 1 HOF
$1299.99
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge N172 Walt Wilmot Tobacco Baseball Card Washington Low Grade
$249.99
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge 490-2 pose Buck West PSA 1.5 Minneapolis
$485.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL CARD CAPT JOHN WARD NEW YORK GIANTS HOF GOODWIN PSA
$2900.00
View Details
1887-1889 N172 Old Judge Walt Wilmot Tobacco Baseball Card Washington Rebacked
$299.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge John Clarkson Throwing Right Arm Extended PSA 3 VG
$3500.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE William "Dad" Clarke Chicago White Stockings SGC #77-5 RARE
$599.99
View Details
Tommy McCarthy 1887 N172 Old Judge Browns HOF Rookie SGC 4 VG-EX
$3500.00
View Details
1880's Antique Style Old Judge Tobacco Baseball Card Advertising Trade Sign 9x36
$99.95
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card BUCK WEST Minneapolis SGC 3 VG
$995.00
View Details
1880's Old Judge Cigarettes Large Lovely Tobacco Trade Card &M
$23.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge C.H. WILLIS - SGC 5.5 EX+
$958.50
View Details
1889 N172 Old Judge #433-7 Charlie Sprague Clevelands SGC 4 None Higher POP 2
$699.99
View Details
1996 Old Judge Vladimir Guerrero BGS 9 MINI HOF🔥🔥
$27.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N174 Mike Clearly SGC 6 POP ONE Hull Collection 2 Higher Gorgeous
$899.00
View Details
1886 1887 N172 Old Judge 193-1 Gleason Portrait SGC A - King Kelly print anomaly
$3500.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
$1395.00
View Details
1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge Prizefighters Tobacco N174 Mick Dooley
$856.10
View Details
1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Lefty Marr SGC 1 PR
$425.00
View Details
1886 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball TOM DALY CHICAGO WHITE SOX SGC 1 1500+ HIT
$595.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge 182-6 pose Emil Geiss Portrait SGC A - Chicago Cubs Pitcher
$425.00
View Details
1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge Prizefighters Tobacco N174 Frank Slavin
$856.10
View Details
1889 N165 Goodwin & Co. Old Judge Baseball Pitcher Games & Sports Series
$689.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #50-1 Charles Buffington Buffinton PSA 4 - Philadelphia
$1625.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #11-1b Cap ANSON - SGC 5+++ HOF Cubs
$34999.99
View Details
1889 Old Judge N172 #150-1 Jay Faatz SGC 1 PR
$475.00
View Details
1887-1889 N172 Old Judge Bobby Wheelock Boston Red Sox Tobacco Baseball Card
$399.99
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Joe Mack Baltimores 286-4 SGC Graded VG-EX 4 Strong!
$3899.99
View Details
1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Hardy Richardson SGC 1 PR
$650.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge DAVE MYSEL T-95 Series Auto /5750 Detroit #25
$2.88
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Sam Trott Baltimores 464-2 SGC Graded Nice Image!
$899.99
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JAMES MCQUAID Denver SGC 2.5
$795.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE P. GUS KROCK VINTAGE CHICAGO BASEBALL CARD FLAWS GOOD MINUS
$299.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JOE SOMMER BALTIMORES SGC 3.5 VG +
$1195.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 Julie Freeman SGC Authentic Altered
$425.00
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge George Pinkney PSA Authentic Altered Brooklyn N172 Goodwin
$705.00
View Details
1888 VINTAGE OLD JUDGE CIGARETTES TRADE CARD/TOP HALF GONE
$250.00
View Details
1889 N172 Old Judge Harry Decker #122-1 SGC 5 P1312
$750.00
View Details
1889 Old Judge Bill McClellan Denver #304-3 SGC 5 P1298
$1300.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card GEORGE PINKNEY OUTDOORS BROOKLYNS SGC 1.5
$895.00
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Wooden Box with Labels + Tax Stamp NICE!
$1599.99
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Baseball Old Judge T-95 Series Complete Card Set 1-36
$12.99
View Details
2016 Goodwin Champions Khatuna Lorig Archery Wood Front Old Judge Back #31 02/08
$19.95
View Details
1888 N173 Old Judge Tobacco Cabinet Checklist Of Baseball Players Goodwin & Co.
$1299.99
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge TATE SEEFRIED T-95 Series Auto /5750 New York
$2.88
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Bill Hutchison/Hutchinson, White Stockings/Cubs
$2.85
View Details
Marshall Boze 1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge T-95 Minis Auto /5750 #7 Auto H2c
$1.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JOHN IRVIN WASHINGTON SGC 2
$795.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card MIKE SLATTERY New York SGC 3 VG
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #299-3 AL MAYS - SGC 5 EX ***RARE!!!***
$1012.50
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge JIMMY HURST T-95 Series Auto /5750 Chicago #19
$3.88
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Edward Knouff, St.Louis Browns (Cardinals)
$2.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge SCRAPPY Carroll ST. PAUL Baseball Card PSA 4 vg/ex
$1395.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge ANDY STEWART T-95 Series Auto /5750 Kansas City
$2.88
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge MATT LUKE T-95 Series Auto /5750 New York #23
$3.88
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge QUILVIO VERAS T-95 Series Auto /5750 Florida 33
$2.88
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BILL BISHOP Pittsburgh PSA 2
$995.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cy Sutcliffe Looking At Ball By Bat PSA 3 P1315
$550.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card DAD CLARKE Chicago SGC 4 VG/EX
$1295.00
View Details
1887 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY NNO VG N172 SGC A BASEBALL INDIANAPOLIS HOOSIERS
$390.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge KYM ASHWORTH T-95 Series Auto /5750 Los Angeles
$2.88
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card John SOWDERS Kansas City Cowboy PSA 5 Centered
$1900.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge Cigarettes N172 George Wood SGC 5 EX
$2500.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge "Handsome" Henry Boyle End Of Pitch SGC 4
$1000.00
View Details
1888 OLD JUDGE / Goodwin Promotional Baseball Card VG *rare tobacco card* DD11
$995.95
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Sam Trott Baltimores 464-5 NO Creases! Sharp Image!
$2899.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge, Dan Brouthers, Detroit Bat/Ready Over Shoulder, PSA Auth.
$2095.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge STACY HOLLINS T-95 Series Auto /5750 Oakland 17
$1.88
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card BILL HOWES Minneapolis SGC 70 5.5 EX+
$1495.00
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Tommy Tucker & Chris Fulmer, Baltimore Orioles
$2.75
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JIM FOGARTY Philadelphia SGC 3.5 VG +
$2695.00
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge Germany Smith SGC Authentic #425-3 Brooklyn New York N172
$493.50
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Danny Richardson NY Bat On Right Shoulder VG-EX+ SGC 55
$500.00
View Details
1996 Signature Rookies Old Judge SCOTT BULLETT T-96 Series Auto /5000 Chicago NL
$2.88
View Details
1888 N172 Old Judge Tobacco Foghorn Tucker Baltimores 465-1 SGC VG 3
$1299.99
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Sam Thompson, Detroit Wolverines (NL) HOF
$3.75
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Denny Lyons, Philadelphia Athletics (A.A.)
$4.00
View Details
1995 Signature Rookies Old Judge SAL FASANO T-95 Series Auto /5750 Kansas City
$10.88
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card HENRY PORTER Brooklyn SGC 50 4 VG/EX
$1395.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Sid Farrar Right Hand At Belt PSA 4 (MC) P1332
$700.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes John Clarkson SGC 40 VG 3 HOF CAREER (328-178)
$3800.00
View Details
Victorian Trade Card Goodwin & Co Old Judge Cigarettes Actress Alma Stanley
$47.50
View Details
1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge Prizefighters Tobacco N174 Ike Weir
$856.10
View Details